Players in bold have been voted off the island.

Bob Gibson                  56
Cal Ripken Jr.              54

Mike Piazza                 49
Kid Nichols                 39
Warren Spahn                24
George Brett                22
Rickey Henderson            16
Joe DiMaggio                12
Mel Ott                      9
Tom Seaver                   7
Eddie Mathews                5
Jimmie Foxx                  3
Nap Lajoie                   1
Joe Morgan                   1
Eddie Collins                1